James-B's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Flash Art Tutorial]

Yay!

This is actually quite an original idea, there is no rule written down on newgrounds.com which says that your flash work is not allowed to be informative. Unfortunately there arent enough genre sections to allow for movies like this so you are going to be poorly marked by the wrong unappriciative audience.

Please dont consider this a stupid flash movie, this probably deserves a higher score than most of the generic shit pumped into newgrounds.com daily. Instead of comparing it to other flash movies i judged it on how useful i found it and wether i had though anyone else would find it useful, also in this case its originality. Unfortunately there wasnt enough content for a really high mark but next time why dont you go for a documentry style animation? Include some humour add a few more techniques to learn, have a step by step tutorial section, maybe even a menu system for different lessons.

DO NOT RUBBISH THIS WORK. It is good, but needs improving on and the right type of open minded voter. Goodluck on your next one! THERE WILL BE A NEXT ONE!!! :)

HNPFL responds:

im glad there are good people like you on NG to identify good and great works through out the portal

[Mystic Island 2]

Sorry

OK this really wasn't good at all, not only was it just a bunch of stick figures of which must of taken him a whole 5 minutes while balancing upside down in a bucket of custard with T W A T written on his forehead, but it was narrow minded stupid and completely un-funny, i think the type of person who made this has a brain the size of his dick, not really that big to be honest.

GolemCC responds:

I take it you're part of the anti-stick league?
And how was it narrow-minded? Would you mind filling me in on that?
Also, are you studying to be a doctor? If not, why do you spend so much time comparing anatomical sizes? But what should I expect from someone whose only movie is entitled "Twat Face"?
Next time you write a review for one of my movies, please give me a reason you didn't like it... this was just ranting.

[The Stick Slayer Slayer]

Hmmm...

Oh dear, I think that spending over 50 hours for something that will "entertain us" was a little silly seeing as i didn't really find it that entertaining and the animation was down-right poor, but on argueing you did have a good story line and you have the basis for some good ideas well i would say keep it up, but urm try harder.

OddJob9 responds:

i had a storyline, wow. i wasnt sure if i did. im not sure if i'll make another one of these but im still gonna make movies and i can only get better